Making and Testing a bronze Must Farm Sickle

I have been on a quest to either make or get my hands on a replica Must Farm bronze age sickle ever since the originals were excavated in 2015/2016 not far from me here in the East Anglian Fens. 

Having and using a tool like this in my hands allows me to fully connect with it, to properly understand how it functions and what it can do. There is only so much you can deduce by just looking at the originals in a museum (as I did at the first opportunity).

My chance to acquire a replica Must Fam sickle came after Dr James Dilley of ancient craft.co.uk was commissioned by the Cambridge Archaeological Unit to create some facsimile Must Farm sickles.  I attended one of James’ excellent Bronze sword casting courses and was able to purchase two precast sickles from him.  The course gave me the opportunity to learn about bronze age metallurgy and get many of my questions on sickles answered (James is a most knowledgeable archaeologist).

Bronze sickles are important as they are considered to be the forerunner of steel scythes that first appeared in the late Iron Age.  There is however much debate, based on scant evidence, about what these bronze age sickles might have been used for (c.900BC). 

As an experienced scythe and hand tool user with 40 years of practical hands-on knowledge of growing and harvesting a very wide range of plants and crops I feel I can gain some insight into the sickle’s potential a usefulness as a tool over a variety of tasks – for myself at least.  Archaeologists will need to use the evidence of context to come to a judgement as to what uses the sickles found at Must Farm were likely to have been used for in the Bronze age.

My video gives a quick 4 minute overview of my sickle project so far. I have been able to haft the sickle and try using it to successfully harvest reeds (one of the potential uses proposed for it).  I plan to add to this blog in more depth over time as I try using the sickle for a variety of seasonal tasks from cereals to grass (the latter more to show how inefficient it is compared to a scythe).

If you would like to read what I have found out about on sickles in the bronze age please do read on (in some depth – sorry I wanted to write up everything for myself so I didn’t forget it).

Bronze Sickle Form

The Must Farm sickles are of a socketed type associated mainly with Britain and Ireland. Like the Ewart Park type bronze sword (which I cast on the course) they seem to represent a home-grown British development; a late Bronze age innovation in design.

Rough cast Ewart Park sword and Must Farm sickle

The Must farm sickles as well as being socketed are distinct in that they are double edged with a mid-rib. The sickle blade is 12 cm long, 4.5mm thick (7mm at rib), with a conical tapered socket c.20mm ID diameter at the widest point. The bronze blade weighs c.180g and the hafted sickle c.270g.

Sickles from Europe tend to either have a tang or knob fittings like the example I bought some years ago (off an ebay antiquities dealer!) Typical European bronze age sickles are single edged with a thickened back rib like a scythe.

my continental style knobbed sickle

Hafting

Six complete bronze sickles, plus fragments from four others sickles, were excavated from the Must Farm site near Peterborough in 2015/2016. Although a hafted bronze axe head was found on this site, with its wooden shaft preserved, none of the sickles had associated wood remains.

Fortunately, from another site the Shinewater sickle was found hafted with a complete handle which informs the reconstruction to haft the Must Farm replicas. This handle is short 16.5 cm long with a bulbous hockey stick shaped end making it fit well and securely in the hand for delivering a strong pulling action. Interestingly to date no preserved handle for a knobbed sickle has been found in Europe.

The Shinewater sickle handle was made from field maple. Whilst I used this as a pattern, I used yew as I don’t have any field maple. Yew is my preferred wood for grips. I love its colours and workability, and I have trees that produce a lot of elbows in which the wood grain conveniently turns the corner. I made two handles: one following the Shinewater pattern as best I could; the other carved slightly more freestyle to what felt most ergonomically comfortable in my hand. Some quite elaborately shaped ergonomic hafts have been found in Europe for tanged sickles.

Peening Bronze

Bronze compared to iron and steel is a soft metal. Freshly cast bronze sickle and sword blades need peening to work harden the crystal structure within the bronze to make the blades tougher and more resilient and to hold an edge.  Much like our steel scythe blades the edge needs peening to thin and profile the edge taper as preparation for honing.  With bronze the work hardening is more generally critical to stiffen the blade and can extend well beyond the edge into the body of the blade itself. The knobbed sickle I have shows evidence of hammering across the entire upper surface of the blade. The bronze edge is unlikely to hold an edge without peening, whereas for steel blades one can get away with just grinding and honing.

There are other differences between bronze and steel.  Importantly bronze work hardens more rapidly than steel. It is therefore easier to over-peen bronze to the point where the metal fails and cracks appear. This can be worked around by periodic annealing to relax the crystal structure by carefully heating the bronze to a dull red then quenching (the opposite of steel which has to cool slowly).

In my own tentative peening trials, with both the sickle and sword, I seemed able to do enough repeated peening passes to achieve the edge I was aiming for without resorting to a round of annealing. I felt that I pushed the metal as far as it would go as I began to see first signs of micro-cracking (although I could not be sure whether these were stress fractures as some followed small flaws in the casting). I did not peen as finely as I would steel as bronze is just not strong enough.

The bevel on the socketed sickle and the sword are two sided as well as being a steeper angle.  This necessitated some modification to my peening set ups. Essentially, I simultaneously used convex bar or ball pein faces on both the anvil and hammers.  I tried quite a combination of hammers and anvil profiles for different parts of the peening operation.

Continental knobbed sickles do have a one-sided bevel like scythes and would have been easier to peen.

I of course had access to hardened steel hammers and anvils. Bronze age metal workers would have used stone and bronze hammers and anvils.

Honing Bronze

Honing a bronze peened edge is pretty much the same process as one would apply to a steel edge. The only difference is the bronze is softer and so requires a lighter touch using finer grits.  I found that an extra fine natural stone in my collection was very good for final honing.  This is a soft stone which produces quite a slurry that was not really very useful on a steel edge but suited bronze.  I made a small whetstone puck from this stone with a convex face to fit the inner curve of my sickle.

I found it difficult to get quite as keen an edge as I can on steel, but I produced an edge that would cut tough reeds with no issue.  Being softer than steel the bronze edge does not last long, needing more frequent attention with a stone, and will as a consequence wear back faster.

Use and Context

The evidence for use and function for bronze sickles comes potentially from three main lines of enquiry.

  • Context: deductions based on the context in which the objects were discovered
  • Edge wear and residue analysis
  • Experimental archaeology: trying the tool out to see how it works on a variety of possible tasks.

Context

Good evidence as to the practical use and function of bronze sickles is scarce. There has been surprisingly little research on this subject and discussions of their actual use is often educated guesswork at best.  There has been a tendency for ancient finds from this period to be enthusiastically assigned high status ceremonial functions such as for use by Druids cutting mistletoe at solstice celebrations.

Bronze sickles are one of the most commonly found tools from the bronze age, second only to bronze axe heads. However sickles excavated from a regular working settlement context are exceptionally rare. This paucity of evidence of association itself does not mean that sickles were not used for crops and therefore just ceremonial. Bronze tools were just too valuable to discard, lose or leave behind as evidence when you moved house. The bronze was a completely recyclable and valuable material (unlike broken pottery or flint).  If your tool became worn or damaged it could be melted down and a new one cast.  The majority (80+%) of sickle finds in Europe come from hoards which are typically collections of scrapped bronze items, often broken up ready for recasting.  Sickles are rarely found with grave goods or as votive offerings in watery places, which again downgrades their possible status as symbols below that of swords, axes and daggers.

The unique nature of the Must Farm site is the incredible rich and complete nature of the context with metalwork, pottery, fabrics, foodstuffs, and wood all present lying together arranged in context; a bronze age moment frozen in time. What is key is that the bronze sickles, together with axes, knives were found in each of the equally well-equipped dwellings (not just in one high-status priest or chieftains hut).  Sickles it would appear were everyday household equipment. This settlement represents a routine dwelling in a rarely excavated fenland setting.

The Must Farm tools are also unique as they are all in a pristine nearly new but used condition. It appears that the settlement was at the time of its catastrophic fire only quite recently built and equipped with the latest gadgets.

Edge wear and residue analysis

Very little if any edge use-wear analysis has been done on bronze sickles by comparison with flint sickles and other tools.  This will in part be because most used sickles were melted and recycled, also perhaps that the more numerous stone sickles are also linked to the dawn of agriculture and attract more research interest, where bronze sickles represent a transition type? Also less glamorous as compared to swords and weapons.

The bronze tools from Must farm are in nearly new condition but do show signs of having been used. Other bronze sickles that do survive to the present in a worn state show significant evidence of reworking by peening and honing to the point where up to 20% of the original form may have been lost.  If used frequently I guess they would not have lasted very long before being recycled.

I have not found any residue analysis reports for bronze sickles, but I have found a study of residue analysis of bronze daggers.  This forensic type analysis is technically challenging as there will not be much residue on the smooth metal after 3000 years, plus analysis must take place on uncontaminated finds fresh from the soil (so unlikely for Must Farm finds).  What the dagger analysis showed was rather than, as previously suggested, daggers being worn as status/virility symbols, the examples in the study had meat and vegetable traces suggesting they had been used as hunting/kitchen knives for processing food.  This emphasising the everyday mundane utility over their more glamorous status.  This is not say that possessing and flaunting these shiny gadgets did not also have show off kudos.  (as I think my new sickle does!).

Testing the Sickle in practical applications

Candidates for usage of the bronze sickles based on the foodstuff and other finds associated with the Must Farm site include cereal crops like emmer wheat, six-row hulled barley (for harvesting both grain and straw) and reeds for thatching roofs. (flax/linseed was also found but this has historically been pulled rather than cut).

In spite of the wetland location of the Must Farm pile-dwellings much of the foods and building materials found have dryland origins suggesting strong dependence on the drier hinterland for resources and the river for transport connections.   The sickles could conceivable have been taken away from the settlement and used for harvesting crops and foraging on a regular basis. The bronze age was a period of intensification of agriculture, particularly cereals, and having this efficient ‘state-of-the-art’ tool to harvest crops would have been absolutely essential.

Reed harvesting for roofing material is a strong candidate for use of the sickle given the immediate wetland location.  This would have been a seasonal (winter) and occasional activity for roof building and repairs, but may have had more significance if reed was cut to be traded as a commodity, perhaps transported by boat as in more recent times within the Norfolk Broads. Perhaps the log boats found at Must Farm were ‘Reed lighters’?

My first impression handling my completed and sharpened replica tool was that it felt good in the hand and it was easy to imagine it being a multi-purpose tool for a wide range of tasks.  This would include tasks frequently associated with sickles of harvesting cereals, but also a useful neat tool to take out to gather many other crops, like vegetables and herbs, and for wild foraging.  The innovation of the double edge with the outer curve sharpened as well as the inner further expands its potential as a multi-tool.  A herb cutter immediately springs to mind.  It is one of those tools that once you have it you would reach for it for a whole variety of tasks.

Over the coming year I plan to try it out for myself on a full range of crops and other tasks, including ancient cereals with John Letts (Archeobotanist and Heritage cereals grower). I will add to this report as I do.

Reeds

I have already been able to go out with the sickle to harvest reed as winter is the season for reed cutting.  It performed well in this task.

The bronze sickle cuts well and efficiently.  I did not take me long to gather my first bundle of cut reed. It is difficult to imagine being able to cut reed as efficiently with stone tools, and practically impossible to harvest without a suitably shaped cutting tool of some type. 

The combination of the hooked sickle blade shape, with the hockey stick handle was perfect for pulling the blade an upward slicing motion though bunches of stems grasped in my left hand.  Sickles and hooks (large sickles) were used for centuries in exactly this way to cut reed.  Scythes were later adopted to cut reed as it eliminates the strain of working bent double, but scythes do not drop the cut stems in neat bundles as the sickle method does.  This is the same historic issue with harvesting cereals, especially top-heavy wheat.  Sickles were historically the principal tool for harvesting cereals (if you can persuade workers to do it).  Scythes were developed for mowing grass.

The sickle was a very handy tool for gathering up and organising bundles of cut reed as well as cleaning the base of the bundles of lose leaf detritus.

Reading list and links

https://www.ancientcraft.co.uk/

http://www.mustfarm.com/

Making Must Farm (Pt.2): A Bronze Sickle.  Mark Knight (CAU) and Dr. James Dilley (AncientCraftUK) https://youtu.be/l9zeYxQMkgk

The Must Farm pile-dwelling settlement. Mark Knight, Rachel Ballantyne, Iona Robinson Zeki and David Gibson.  Antiquity. Published online: 12 June 2019  https://peterborougharchaeology.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/06/The-Must-Farm-Pile-Dwelling-Settlement-Antiquity.pdf

Journal of Conservation and Museum Studies, Vol 4 (1998) A Late Bronze Age Sickle from Shinewater Park: The Treatment of a Waterlogged Composite ANN BRYSBAERT Available from: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/269836348_A_Late_Bronze_Age_Sickle_from_Shinewater_Park_The_Treatment_of_a_Waterlogged_Composite.

Arnoldussen, S., & Steegstra, H. (2016). A bronze harvest: Dutch Bronze Age sickles in their European context. Palaeohistoria, 57/58, 63-109.A BRONZE HARVEST: DUTCH BRONZE AGE SICKLES IN THEIR EUROPEAN CONTEXT

“If I had a hammer”: Bronze Age metalworkers and their tools Dr Linda Boutoille https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OoENsbpdReQ

2 thoughts on “Making and Testing a bronze Must Farm Sickle”

    1. Tom, yes I am trying to get the archaeologists interested through James Dilley my Instructor and himself an archaeologist. These archaeologists are however not very good at responding to amateurs like myself.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *